Reporting Claims After Hours

If you are unable to contact your agent and need to report a claim, you can call the company claim numbers.

Here is a list of company claim telephone numbers you can call after normal business hours. When you call, please have your policy number ready.

American Modern Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 375-2075

Report Online

Andover Companies (Cambridge Mutual/Merrimack Mutual)

Toll Free: (800) 225-0770

Chubb Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 252-4670

Report Online

Commerce Insurance (Citation)

Toll Free: (800) 221-1605

Encompass Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 588-7400

Fidelity Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 725-9472

Fireman's Fund

Toll Free: (888) 347-3428

Foremost Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 527-3905

Report Online

Hanover Insurance (Citizens, Mass Bay)

Toll Free: (800) 628-0250

Web: Report Online

Hartford Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 327-3636

Web: Report Online

Hingham Mutual Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 341-8200

Mass Property Insurance Underwriting Association (FAIR Plan)

Toll Free: (800) 392-6108

Report Online

Merchants Insurance

Toll Free (888) 644-6680

MiddleOak Insurance (Holyoke Mutual)

Toll Free: (800) 225-2533

Report Online

New London County

Toll Free: (800) 621-5410

Norfolk and Dedham Insurance (Fitchburg Mutual)

Toll Free: (800) 688-1825

Preferred Mutual Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 333-7642

Report Online

Quincy Mutual Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 490-0047

Safeco Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 332-3226

Safety Insurance

Phone: (617) 951-0600

Traveler's Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 252-4633

Union Mutual Insurance (New England Guaranty)

Toll Free: (800) 671-8552

Vermont Mutual Insurance

Toll Free: (800) 435-0397

Zurich Insurance (Maryland Casualty Insurance)

Toll Free: (800) 987-3373

Report Online